Levinsons classic textbook on pragmatics, which in turn draws on a list produced by lauri karttunen. While burtonroberts 1989a, 1989b saw the mn account of presuppositiondenials as providing strong support for his semantic theory of presupposition, i have offered a multilayered pragmatic. A presupposition is something that you assume to be true, especially something which you. Exercise presuppositions lexical resource semantics. This is an introduction to pragmatics, the study of how people make sense of each other linguistically.
In this pragmatics point of view, sentences are distinguished into three types. The classic and often mentioned example of this is, the king of france is not ill. While bill was looking for the receipt, mary continued work on the form. May 05, 2020 a presupposition may be considered actual or potential based on the presentation of the information being presupposed. These maxims are unstated assumptions we have in conversations. We make use of the theory of logical consequence operation as a general framework to show that it is impossible to find a logical consequence operation which mirrors the philosophical. A presupposition may be considered actual or potential based on the presentation of the information being presupposed. The notion of presupposition emerged originally from a concern in philosophy with the nature of. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Types of presuppostions make your conversational contribution such as is required, at the stage at which it occurs, by the accepted purpose or direction of the talk exchange in which you are engaged. Entailment, presupposition, and implicature 3,205 words, approx. However, there are other situations in which presupposition remains and entailment disappears.
This inference is also an implicational relation but it is. Presupposition the concept of presupposition is often treated as the. The statement sarah said that dave just got back from florida presupposes that there is a unique entity called sarah and that there is a unique entity called dave who was, until recently, in florida. Presupposition notes stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Implicature should not be confused with entailment which is not covered in this book and presupposition.
Some have argued that this is not a desirable property for entailment and that what is needed is a notion of relevant entailmentsee the entry on relevance logic. Presuppositions are assumptions that the speaker makes, and assumes that the. Sometimes, speaking loosely, we talk as though it were a relation between sentences. Nov 11, 20 presupposition and entailment describe two different aspects of information that need not be stated as speakers assume it is already known by listeners these concepts used to be much more central to pragmatics than they are now, but they are still important to understand the relationship between pragmatics and semantics presupposition. Presupposition and entailment presupposition types of. Gatri asti putri indarti 2016, distinguishing entailment and presupposition under negation test. Read the bulletpoint statements and try to detect the presuppositions in each. Presupposition and implicature under negation request pdf. Much more central to pragmatics in the past than now. Veronica marin bedoya presupposition and entailment maria jose hernandez paola prada entailement depend on sentence meaning not the context in which the sentence is used. Download our english dictionary apps available for both ios and android. Entailment and presupposition by zainurrahman entailment definition.
Intuitively, a presupposition constitutes a necessary assumption required to understand the meaning of a sentence. Presupposition, implicature and context in text understanding. The entailment relation here results from a syntactic source. To assist you in detecting the different types of presupposition common in natural language some useful and illustrative examples follow. Keplers existence is a condition for the bivalence of the statement kepler died in misery. If x presupposes y, the negative counterpart of x also presupposes y. Entailments are inferences that can be drawn solely from our knowledge about the semantic relationship in a language. Rc hums 392 english grammar and meaning triggers for. For example, the question of whether i will turn 28 this year first of all presupposes that i am real. Presupposition and entailment21 logical consequence. Morgan, jerry, 1969, on the treatment of presupposition in transformational grammar, in papers from the fifth regional meeting, chicago linguistic society, university of chicago, 16777. Marys brother bought something, bought three animal, two horses, one horse etc.
While burtonroberts 1989a, 1989b saw the mn account of presupposition denials as providing strong support for his semantic theory of presupposition, i have offered a multilayered pragmatic. Bergmann, merrie, notre dame journal of formal logic, 1982. Presupposition definition in the cambridge english dictionary. T he story consists of some characteristic which has a relatedness each other such as. This sentence presupposes that there is a king of france, which there is currently not. The colonels lady social life point of view analysis prose analysis. Entailment also differs from presupposition in that in presupposition, the truth of what one is presupposing is taken for granted. Group assignment the colonels lady is a short story written by w. Marys brother bought three horses a presupposition is something the speaker assumes to be the case prior to making an utterance. A presupposition trigger is a lexical item or linguistic construction which is responsible for the presupposition, and thus triggers it. Presupposition and entailment by veronica marin on prezi. Linguisticspragmatics wikibooks, open books for an open world.
Lx 502 conversational implicatures boston university. Presupposition and entailment slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Presupposition definition and meaning collins english. It has been argued that the latter is a presupposition, a conversational implicature, and an entailment. Entailment is related to the concepts of presupposition and implicature. Conversational implicatures lx 502 semantics i oct 2, 2008 1. The following is a selection of presuppositional triggers following stephen c. Towards a common logical semantics for presupposition and entailment, journal of semantics, 9. Listen to the audio pronunciation in the cambridge english dictionary. Both entailment and presupposition have an automatic relationship based on the context. Strawson provides technical development of his partial logical approach to presupposition in strawson 1952.
Generally, an ebook can be downloaded in five minutes or less. The philosophical controversy surrounding presupposition comes in at the very beginning determining whether these are genuine cases of presupposition or are merely cases of entailment. The author explains, and illustrates, basic concepts such as the cooperative principle, deixis, and speech acts, providing a clear, concise foundation for further study. S semantically presupposes p if and only if p is true whenever s is true or false. Temporal clauses subordinate clauses introduced by temporal conjunctions before he died, frege hadhadnt written about presuppositions. Presupposition and implicature 5 dominant one, though, at present, it probably manifests itself largely as noncommitment about the full picture even as more and more of the heavylifting is assigned to the pragmatics abbott, 2006. But it is not clear whether it is an undesirable property for logics of presupposition.
Entailment is a relation between sentence meanings, or propositions. In pragmatics entailment is the relationship between two sentences where the truth of one a requires the truth of the other b. Further early discussion of strawsons proposals is found in sellars 1954, strawson 1954, and nerlich 1967. Presuppositions if entailments are crucial semantic relation, presuppositions, it may be said, are typical pragmatic relation. This knowledge allows us to communicate much more than we actually say. Presuppositions, entailment and implicatures by flavia. Banjar presupposition seems to contrast with entailment.
Linguistics 103 language structure and verbal art entailment. Entailmentit is something that logically follows fromwhat is asserted in the utterance. Strawsonian notion of presupposition is dependent on the notion of logical entailment. These dont seem really to be true or falsethey just seem like presupposition failures.
Rc hums 392 english grammar and meaning triggers for presupposition and entailment 7. There is another kind of inference, called a presupposition, that is not an entailment but also cannot be classified as abductive or inductive. Bill was looking for the receipt for some period of time. Presupposition definition, to suppose or assume beforehand. Implicature entailment a sentence s entails a proposition p if p is true whenever s is true. Presupposition meaning in the cambridge english dictionary. Presupposition definition of presupposition by the free. For example, the sentence a the president was assassinated. Presupposition and implicature stanford university.
Entailment entailment a the evil overlord assassinated the man in the red shirt. Implicatures are not logical necessities which you can deduce from the sentence, while entailment and most presuppositions are. Ginsberg, mitchell, notre dame journal of formal logic, 1972. Expressibility in twodimensional languages for presupposition. Exercise presupposition or entailment lexical resource. Mary exists, mary has a brother, mary has only one brother, marys brother is rich. John knew that there was a mountain behind the house. Presupposition refers to a basic premise that is assumed to be true before entailment takes place.
Presupposition and entailment describe two different aspects of information that need not be stated as speakers assume it is already known by listeners these concepts used to be much more central to pragmatics than they are now, but they are still important to understand the relationship between pragmatics and semantics presupposition. The beginnings of logic lie in a search for the principles of valid argument and inference. Decide whether in the following examples the second sentence is a presupposition or an entailment of the first one. The numerical syllogism and existential presupposition murphree, wallace a. Only, presupposition and implicature the meaning of the english adverb only has been the subject of intense debate. This paper examines the roles which presupposition and implicature. Introduction with entailments and presuppositions under our belts, i turn briefly to one other kind of inference called a conversational implicature or simply an implicature. As mentioned above, negation is a typical example for the distinction between presupposition and entailment, for presupposition is stable under negation while entailment isnt. The study of logic comes from the greek, most famously from aristotle who came up with a logical argument in three steps called modus tollens. Logic and truth it is claimed that the tools of logic can be used to represent semantic meaning. Presupposition can also be seen as a relation between propositions, although many linguists including george yule prefer to see presupposition as strictly pragmatic, and a relation between. Entailment also happens when one set of objects is included in anothers.
1431 845 8 661 278 341 650 100 1610 1054 1291 1394 1571 1395 1287 1579 1233 669 220 860 1312 689 1354 673 1650 1156 751 1055 779 836 274 1364 564 1525 275 949 1574 997 450 816 252 233 820 1116 1020 356 79